Faculty Letter Regarding Due Process

Faculty Letter Regarding Due Process

To President Kornbluth, Chancellor Nobles, Provost Barnhart, Chair of Faculty Fuller, and Professor Schapiro,

We the undersigned faculty and staff are issuing an urgent call for due process for our students facing hastily enacted interim suspensions.

While we understand there are complex, fast-moving situations at play, the current decision to issue a set of “interim suspensions” without any meaningful due process involving a full Committee on Discipline hearing goes against not only the spirit of MIT, but the very foundations of U.S. legal frameworks which always assume that the accused have a right to a full hearing of evidence as well as advisement in addressing the accusation. While warnings were issued, a full disciplinary process before punishment is vital. While the disciplinary action may end up being warranted, right now a commitment to due process has been completely bypassed.​​​​​​​

This decision is putting students in immediate and profound material jeopardy affecting their residency status, their access to housing and food, their ability to continue with their education and, in some cases, even graduate. In practice, an interim suspension is actually acting as a full one, particularly for international students.

By Wednesday evening, May 8, more than twenty students have been identified as having received letters detailing interim suspensions for their “participation in the encampment” — a vague allegation that could include hundreds of students. At least 17 cases involve planned removal of access to food (meal plans) and housing (access to dorm rooms). In one case, the student has a wife and a 5-year-old daughter who will soon also be without access to housing.

Faculty members working with students facing interim suspensions are already witnessing errors in the process of identifying students. In one case, a Palestinian student who had been avoiding the encampment since Monday received a suspension notice. This is an indication that the hastily enacted process of identifying (through unclear means and methods) and preemptively punishing students is likely to be flawed.

We call on the administration to immediately rescind the interim suspensions and work with COD to manage a disciplinary process that maintains a more transparent, fair, and ethically coherent approach.

Signed,

Faculty

  1. Ryan Aasen, Visiting Lecturer, ACT
  2. Fatin Abbas, Lecturer, CMS/W
  3. Mohamed Abdelhafez, Lecturer, Physics
  4. Fadel Adib, Associate Professor, Media Lab & EECS
  5. Sana Aiyar, ​​​Associate Professor, History
  6. Anant Agarwal, Professor, EECS/CSAIL
  7. Azra Aksamija, Professor, ACT
  8. Adam Albright, Professor, Linguistics
  9. Sandy Alexandre, Associate Professor, Literature
  10. Latifa Alkhayat, Teaching Fellow, Architecture
  11. Abdullah Almaatouq, Assistant Professor, Sloan School of Management
  12. Saman Amarasinghe, Professor, EECS/CSAIL
  13. Katya Arquilla, Visiting Assistant Professor, AeroAstro
  14. Amir Anvari, Assistant Professor, Linguistics & Philosophy
  15. Athulya Aravind, Associate Professor of Linguistics, Linguistics and Philosophy
  16. Seth Avecilla, Technical Instructor, Morningside Academy for Design
  17. Vivek Bald, Associate Professor, CMS/W
  18. Dwaipayan Banerjee, Associate Professor, STS
  19. Roi Salgueiro Barrio, Lecturer, Architecture
  20. Kim Bath, Lecturer, CMS/W
  21. Sara Beery, Assistant Professor, EECS
  22. Caroline Beimford, Lecturer, CMS/W & WRAP
  23. Edmund Bertschinger, Professor, Physics
  24. Robert C Berwick, Professor, EECS
  25. Lydia Bourouiba, Associate Professor, Departments of Civil and Environmental Engineering and Mechanical Engineering, & Institute for Medical Engineering and Science
  26. Kate Brown, Thomas Siebel Distinguished Professor in the History of Science, STS
  27. Karilyn Crockett, Assistant Professor, Department of Urban Studies & Planning
  28. Christopher Cullen, Lecturer, MIT Sloan
  29. Catherine D’Ignazio, Associate Professor of Urban Science and Planning, Department of Urban Studies and Planning
  30. Michel DeGraff, Professor, Linguistics
  31. Junot Díaz, Professor, CMS/Writing
  32. Tawanna R. Dillahunt, MLK Visiting Scholar, Department of Urban Studies and Planning
  33. Nilma Dominique, Lecturer, Global Languages
  34. Kevin Dorst, Associate Professor, Linguistics and Philosophy
  35. Peter Dourmashkin, Senior Lecturer, Physics
  36. Caitlyn Doyle, Lecturer, Literature
  37. Eric Driscoll, Lecturer, History and Literature
  38. Fabio Duarte, Lecturer, Principal Research Scientist, Urban Studies and Planning
  39. Paloma Duong, Associate Professor, CMS/W
  40. Arindam Dutta, Professor, Architecture
  41. Laura Finch, Assistant Professor, Literature
  42. Danny Fox, Professor, Linguistics and Philosophy
  43. Elizabeth Fox, Lecturer, CMS/Writing
  44. Giada Franz, Instructor, Mathematics
  45. Nuh Gedik, Donner Professor of Physics, RLE
  46. Erin Genia, Visiting Lecturer, ACT
  47. Marzyeh Ghassemi, Assistant Professor, EECS/IMES
  48. Ahmed Ghoniem, Professor, Mechanical Engineering
  49. Rania Ghosn, Associate Professor, Architecture
  50. Ezra Haber Glenn. Lecturer; co-chair, MCP Committee, Department of Urban Studies and Planning
  51. Marah Gubar, Associate Professor, CMS/W
  52. Huma Gupta, Assistant Professor, Architecture
  53. Wesley L. Harris, Professor of Aeronautics and Astronautics, AeroAstro
  54. Charles Harvey, Professor, Civil and Environmental Engineering
  55. Sally Haslanger, Ford Professor of Philosophy, Affiliate in WGS and D-Lab
  56. Thomas Heldt, Associate Professor of Electrical & Biomedical Engineering, EECS/IMES/RLE
  57. Stefan Helmreich, Professor, Anthropology
  58. Maya Honda, Lecturer, Linguistics
  59. Caley Horan, Associate Professor, History
  60. Sabine Iatridou, Professor, Linguistics and Philosophy
  61. Noel Jackson, Associate Professor, Literature
  62. Erica Caple James, Professor of Medical Anthropology and Urban Studies, Department of Urban Studies and Planning
  63. Nancy Kanwisher, Professor, Brain and Cognitive Sciences
  64. Dina Katabi, Professor, EECS
  65. Wyn Kelley, Senior Lecturer, Literature
  66. Michael J. Kenstowicz, Professor, Dept. of Linguistics
  67. Bo-Won Keum, Lecturer, Architecture
  68. Justin Khoo, Associate Professor, Linguistics and Philosophy
  69. Yoon Kim, Assistant Professor, EECS
  70. Jonathan King, Prof. of Molecular Biology Emeritus
  71. Jaffer Kolb, Lecturer, Architecture
  72. Crystal Lee, Assistant Professor, CMS/W
  73. Helen Elaine Lee, Professor, CMS/W
  74. Thomas Levenson, Professor, CMS/W
  75. Ben Mangrum, Assistant Professor, Literature
  76. Kenneth R. Manning, Thomas Meloy Professor of Rhetoric and of the History of Science, STS & CMS/W
  77. Admir Masic, Associate Professor, CEE
  78. Youssef Marzouk, Professor, AeroAstro
  79. Chakanetsa Mavhunga, Professor, Program in STS
  80. Libby McDonald, Lecturer, D-Lab
  81. Ceasar McDowell, Professor of Practice of Civic Design, Department of Urban Studies and Planning
  82. David McGee, Associate Professor, Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences
  83. Vann McGee, Professor emeritus, Linguistics and Philosophy
  84. William McKenna, Technical Lecturer, Morningside Academy of Design
  85. Eden Medina, Associate Professor, STS
  86. Janis Melvold. Lecturer, CMS/W WRAP
  87. Hector Membreno-Canales, Lecturer, ACT
  88. Ana Miljački, Professor, Architecture
  89. Haynes Miller, Professor of Mathematics, Emeritus
  90. Susan Murcott, Lecturer, D-Lab
  91. Hiromu Nagahara, Associate Professor, History
  92. Mohamad Nahleh, Lecturer, Architecture
  93. Richard Nielsen, Associate Professor, Political Science
  94. Jess Osserman, Technical Instructor, Project Manus
  95. Kenneth Oye, Professor, Political Science, Center for International Studies, IDSS
  96. Tanalís Padilla, Professor of History
  97. Bruno Perreau, Cynthia L. Reed Professor of French Studies, Literature
  98. Ruth Perry, Ann Fetter Friedlaender Professor of Humanities, Emeritus, Literature
  99. David Pesetsky, Professor, Linguistics
  100. Jean-Luc Pierite, MLK Visiting Scholar, Department of Urban Studies and Planning
  101. Tobias Putrih, Lecturer, ACT
  102. Nasser Rabbat, Professor, Architecture
  103. Balakrishnan Rajagopal, Associate Professor, Urban Studies and Planning
  104. Margery Resnick, Associate Professor, Literature
  105. Mitchel Resnick, Professor, MIT Media Lab
  106. Norvin Richards, Professor, Linguistics
  107. Eric Robsky Huntley, Lecturer in Urban Science and Planning, Department of Urban Studies and Planning
  108. Paul Roquet, Associate Professor, CMS/W
  109. Lawrence Sass, Professor, Architecture
  110. Arvind Satyanarayan, Associate Professor, EECS/CSAIL
  111. Robin Wolfe Scheffler, Associate Professor, STS
  112. Edward Schiappa, Professor, CMS/W
  113. Viola Schmitt, Visiting Assciate Professor, Linguistics
  114. Ben Schneider, Ford International Professor of Political Science, Political Science
  115. Kieran Setiya, Professor of Philosophy, Department of Linguistics and Philosophy
  116. Andres Sevtsuk, Associate Professor, Urban Studies and Planning
  117. Lisbeth Shepherd, Lecturer, Architecture
  118. Rosalyne Shieh, Assistant Professor, Architecture
  119. Peter Shor, Professor, Mathematics, CSAIL, CTP
  120. Matthew Shoulders, Professor, Chemistry
  121. Nida Sinnokrot, Associate Professor, ACT
  122. Amy Smith, Founding Director, MIT D-Lab
  123. Raechel Soicher, Assistant Director of Research and Evaluation, Teaching + Learning Lab
  124. Susan Solomon, Martin Professor of Environmental Studies, Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences
  125. Donca Steriade, Professor, Linguistics
  126. Jessie Stickgold-Sarah, Lecturer, CMS/W WRAP
  127. Bettina Stoetzer, Associate Professor, Anthropology
  128. Adam Subhas, WHOI Associate Scientist and faculty in the MIT-WHOI Joint Program
  129. Abha Sur, Lecturer, WGS
  130. Mriganka Sur, Professor, Brain and Cognitive Science
  131. Julien Tailleur, Associate Professor, Physics
  132. T.L. Taylor, Professor, CMS/W​​​​​​​
  133. Joaquin Terrones, Lecturer, Literature & WGS
  134. Martha Thompson, Lecturer, D-Lab
  135. Michael Trice, Lecturer, CMS/W
  136. Franz-Joseph Ulm, Professor, Civil and Environmental Engineering
  137. Gediminas Urbonas, Associate Professor, ACT
  138. Andrea Walsh, Lecturer, CMS/Writing
  139. Craig S. Wilder, Professor of History, History
  140. Brianna Williams, Lecturer, CMS/W & WGS, SHASS
  141. John Willis, Visiting Lecturer, MIT Program in Art, Culture and Technology, Professor of Photography, Emeritus
  142. Ashia Wilson, Assistant Professor, EECS
  143. Danielle Wood, Assistant Professor of Media Arts and Sciences/Aeronautics and Astronautics, Media Lab
  144. Elizabeth Wood, Professor, History
  145. George Verghese, Professor (post-tenure), EECS
  146. Kai von Fintel, Andrew W. Mellon Professor, Linguistics
  147. Stephen Yablo, Professor, Linguistics and Philosophy
  148. Kamal Youcef-Toumi, Professor, Mechanical Engineering
  149. Anonymous Lecturer
  150. Anonymous Assistant Professor
  151. Anonymous Lecturer
  152. Anonymous Assistant Professor
  153. Anonymous Assistant Professor
  154. Anonymous Lecturer

Signatories for formal letter as of 5/10, 6p (one staff member inadvertently included, now listed below)

Broader MIT community signatories since formal submission, non-alphabetical (posted here only). Please be patient with updates, they are done manually.

  1. Elise Newman, Post-doc, Linguistics and Philosophy
  2. Anonymous Professor
  3. Christelle Hayles, DEI Specialist, Chemical Engineering
  4. Phil Thompson, Professor, Department of Uban Studies and Planning
  5. Latifa Alkhayat, Teaching Fellow, Architecture
  6. Ian Murray, Program Assistant, CAPD
  7. Anonymous Administrative Assistant
  8. Naomi Gutierrez, Communications and Alumni Administrator, System Design and Management
  9. Anonymous Staff
  10. Wilder Moss, Thesis Project Associate, MIT Libraries
  11. Rebecca Tibbitts, Processing Associate, MIT Libraries
  12. Cecilia Talamantes, Sr Analyst, VPF
  13. Georgina Lewis, Interlibrary Borrowing Associate, MIT Libraries
  14. Adam Jazairi, Software Engineer, MIT Libraries
  15. Eugenia Beh, Librarian, MIT Libraries
  16. Lauren Fairman, Development Associate, MIT Libraries
  17. Sadie Roosa, Librarian, MIT Libraries
  18. Cam West, Library Assistant, MIT Libraries
  19. Thera Webb, Archivist, MIT Libraries
  20. Sharifa Alghowinem, Research Scientist, Media Arts and Sciences
  21. Marcella Tam, Collection Strategist for Arts, Humanities, Social Sciences, MIT Libraries
  22. Danforth Nicholas, Senior Financial Officer, DMSE
  23. Ned Wolfe, Marketing and Communications Assistant, MIT Libraries
  24. Kendall Dawson, Access Services Associate, MIT Libraries
  25. Erica, Library Access Services Associate, MIT Libraries
  26. Anonymous Staff
  27. Stacey Lantz, Program Manager, Women’s and Gender Studies
  28. Anonymous Staff
  29. Elanienne Coste, Library Assistant, IDLA
  30. Claire Berman, Librarian for Mechanical Engineering, MIT Libraries
  31. Maddie, Administrative Assistant, MIT Libraries
  32. Lara Day, Library Associate, MIT Libraries
  33. Anonymous Staff
  34. Matt Bernhardt, Senior Web Developer, MIT Libraries
  35. Anonymous Staff
  36. Anonymous Staff
  37. Amy Smith, Founding Director, D-Lab
  38. Olivia De Lisle, Library Scanning and Access Services Assistant, MIT Libraries
  39. Simon K. Wolfe, Collections Assistant, MIT Museums
  40. Galen March, Access Services Assistant, MIT Libraries
  41. Palak Patel, Internal Communications Coordinator, MIT Libraries
  42. Ken Urban, Senior Lecturer and Director of Dramatic Writing, Music and Theater Arts
  43. Robin Celikates, Visiting Scholar (Professor of Philosophy, FU Berlin), Linguistics and Philosophy
  44. Jad Kabbara, Research Scientist, Media Lab
  45. J. Yolande Daniels, Associate Professor, SA+P
  46. Anna Beltramini, Research Technician, Brain and Cognitive Sciences
  47. Lukas Metzner, Technical Associate, Brain and Cognitive Sciences
  48. Hannah Cross, Administrative Assistant, Chemical Engineering
  49. Anonymous Graduate Student
  50. Hanna Flores, Graduate Worker, Biology
  51. Naomh Fairweather, Administrative Assistant II, ChemE
  52. Vanmey Ma, Program Assistant, WGS
  53. Ryan Burrow, Associate Technical Staff, Lincoln Lab
  54. Rebekah Oden, Access Services Assistant, MIT Libraries
  55. Natalie Rusk, Research Scientist, MAS
  56. Chanda Prescod-Weinstein, Research Affiliate, STS
  57. Dina M. Asfaha, Post-doctoral Associate, Anthro
  58. Drew Story, Managing Director, MIT Policy Lab
  59. Jeremy Rossen, Senior Program Coordinator, IDSS
  60. Lori Breslow, Senior Lecturer, Sloan
  61. Anne Whiston Spirn, Professor of Landscape Architecture and Planning, Urban Studies and Planning
  62. Sam Stuewe, CBDC Software Engineer, MIT Media Lab – MIT DCI
  63. Naomi Scheman, Research Associate, Philosophy
  64. Richard Solomon, Political Science
  65. Christopher Cummins, Henry Dreyfus Professor of Chemistry, Chemistry
  66. Ahmad Zakka, Instructor, D-Lab
  67. H. Azzouz, Graduate Student, EECS
  68. Christina Couch, Lecturer, CMS/W
  69. Ece turnator, Librarian, MIT Libraries
  70. Caroline White-Nockleby, PhD candidate, HASTS
  71. Alona Bach, PhD candidate, HASTS
  72. James McKeon, Administrative Assistant, IMES
  73. Maria Segala, Data, Reporting, and Grants Administrator, Jameel World Education Lab, Open Learning
  74. J. Darcy Duke, Head, UX and Web Services, Head, UX and Web Services
  75. Julia Menzel, PhD candidate, HASTS
  76. Anthony Zannino, Assistant Editor, MIT Press
  77. Malerie Lovejoy, Acquisitions Assistant, MIT Press
  78. Isabelle Bitman, Program Administrator, MISTI
  79. Carrie Norman, Assistant Professor, Architecture
  80. Cherry Ibrahim, HR Generalist, MIT Libraries
  81. Jake Lewis, Access Services Associate, MIT Libraries
  82. Cadence Seeger, Financial Assistant III, DMSE
  83. Aya Ross, Administrative Assistant, MIT Libraries
  84. Marge Encomienda, Senior Designer, MIT Press
  85. Yekaterina Sokol, Reporting & Data Analyst, VPR
  86. Timothy Loh, PhD candidate, HASTS
  87. Nadia Christidi, PhD candidate, HASTS
  88. Kirsten Levandowski, Affiliate, Brain and Cognitive Sciences
  89. Naomi Scheman, Research Associate, Philosophy and Linguistics
  90. David Olsen, Publicist, MIT Press
  91. Victoria Beja-Glasser, Postdoctoral Fellow, Brain and Cognitive Sciences
  92. Anonymous, Access Services Assistant, Libraries
  93. Mary Jane Daly, Lecturer, Professional Development Director, Department of Urban Studies & Planning
  94. Nicholas Farmer, Administrative Assistant, NSE
  95. Anonymous Staff
  96. Anna Gibson, Postdoctoral Associate, CMS/W
  97. Alejandra Villa, Admin Staff
  98. Emma Noble Smith, J-PAL
  99. Leah Coughlan, Development Associate, Resource Development
  100. Anonymous Staff, MIT Division of Comparative Medicine
  101. Lily Chung, Grad Student, EECS
  102. Gabriela Diaz Quinones, Program Assistant, MISTI
  103. Rebecca Thorndike-Breeze, Lecturer II, WRAP/CMSW
  104. Jacques Klapisch, Marketing and Communications Coordinator, Alumni Association
  105. Anonymous Research Technician, Brain and Cognitive Sciences
  106. Anonymous Staff, MIT Sloan Executive Education
  107. Elizabeth Nelson, Technical Associate, Koch Institute
  108. Nicole Lindsay-Mosher, Post-Doc, Biology
  109. Boyd Ruamcharoen, PhD Candidate, HASTS
  110. Anonymous, AA2 CEE
  111. Rachel Van Unen, Archival Processing Manager, MIT Libraries
  112. Anonymous Staff
  113. Nada El-Alami, ORSEL
  114. Vanmey Ma, Program Assistant, Women’s and Gender Studies
  115. Gregory Kahanamoku-Meyer, Postdoctoral Associate, RLE
  116. Rupal Jain, Senior Manager of Creative Learning, Media Lab
  117. Dan Sweeney, Lecturer, D-Lab
  118. Laura Anderson Barbata, Lecturer, ACT
  119. Julia Lanigan, Acquisitions Associate, Libraries
  120. Ruthann Thomas, Associate Director of Teaching + Learning, Teaching + Learning Lab
  121. Adelaide Zollinger, Director of Communications, Morningside Academy of Design
  122. Erica, Library Access Services Associate, MIT Libraries
  123. Robert C Berwick, Professor of Computer Science, EECS
  124. Marion Cunningham, Associate Director Administration, Morningside Academy for Design
  125. Adam Patch, Computer/Data Scientist, Koch Institute
  126. Malick Ghachem, Professor, History
  127. Alexandria Wilde, Visitor Experience, MIT Museum
  128. Sita Costello, Program assistant for personal & professional development programs, OME
  129. Daniel Estandian, Alumni, Brain and Cognitive Science
  130. Vivishek Sudhir, Class of 1957 Career Development Professor, Mechanical Engineering
  131. Bianca Lepe, Biological Engineering
  132. J. Yolande Daniels, Associate Professor, SA&P
  133. Greg M. Epstein, Humanist Chaplain at MIT, ORSEL
  134. Matthew Browne, Acquisitions Editor, MIT Press
  135. Xinghui Yin, Research Scientist, Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Research
  136. Clifton G. Fonstad, Emeritus Professor, EECS
  137. Brian Neltner, Technical Instructor, DMSE
  138. Julia Ortony, Visiting Associate Professor, Materials Science and Engineering
  139. ShanTil Yell, Administrative Assistant, DMSE
  140. Marine Bender, Financial Coordinator I, DMSE
  141. Ryan Kendall, Sr. Administrative Assistant, DMSE
  142. Rhea Vedro, Technical Instructor & Artist in Residence, DMSE

updated 5/24, 12:30pm